Pinch Pie

My dad turns 57 on January 2nd, but since I’ll be back in Philly by then, we are celebrating tonight. It will be a little party, just some family and close friends. We’re having teriyaki beef stroganoff, steamed broccoli and pinch pie.

One of the traditions in my family, initiated by my grandma Bunny (dad’s mom), is that the birthday boy or girl gets to pick their birthday dinner. No request goes unfulfilled, which is why while I was growing up we had sushi (uncle Bill) as well as hot dogs and corn on the cob (me at age 6). While the main courses run the gamut, the dessert is almost always the same. Because if you’re smart, you ask for pinch pie.

Pinch pie isn’t really a pie at all. It is a big meringue shell, that you fill with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream and strawberries. Some time during the 80’s, one of my dad’s brothers came up with the idea to sprinkle toasted slivered almonds on top, an addition we’ve kept, because it’s just so darn good.

Bunny first made pinch pie in the 40’s, as a special Valentine’s Day dessert for her husband. It was a recipe she cut out of a lady’s magazine, although she was never the lady’s magazine type. She made the shell in the shape of a heart, and picked the white and red fillings to compliment the holiday. I imagine her, standing in the kitchen of her farmhouse in Virginia, apron wrapped about her waist, her feet in old canvas sneakers, whipping both air and love into that bowl of egg whites as she kept one eye on her boys.

When my family moved to Portland, we were no longer within birthday dinner range of Bunny’s big house in Woodland Hills, CA. I would call her on birthdays, to have her talk me through the recipe for pinch pie, one more time. Each time we talked, I wrote down the instructions, but I still liked to call, for the connection and the encouragement. Bunny died when I was 14, so I can’t call her for tips anymore. But I think of her, as I stand at the counter in my parents’ kitchen, the 5 by 7 recipe card with my 11 year old handwriting in front me for reference, whipping love into egg whites.

Pinch Pie Shell

6 room temperature egg whites
1 teaspoon of cream of tartar
1 1/2 cups of sugar
1 teaspoon of vanilla extract (please, use the good stuff)

Beat the 6 egg whites with the cream of tartar on the lowest speed the mixer has, until they start to foam up. You beat them on low, because you don’t want to break the long, thin strands of proteins in the egg whites. They help the mixture get stiff, and you are going to sculpt a bowl out of this stuff, you want it as stiff as possible.

Slowly add the sugar, in about four parts and keep blending.

When you are almost finished, add the vanilla. You know that you are done beating the eggs when it looks glossy, and it stands up in sticky peaks when you remove the beaters.

These days I make it on a sheet of parchment paper, laid on a pizza pan, but the original recipe calls for a buttered platter (a buttered cookie sheet also works. Do not spread this out on tin foil, it is impossible to remove). Take half the mixture and plop it out in the middle of the pan and spread it out to make the floor. Then start building the walls around the edges, sculpting them thick and as tall as you can make them.

Put it in a 225 degree oven for about an hour (you aren’t really baking it so much as drying it out). When it’s done, put it up someplace high, because people like to break little pieces of it off before it’s time for dessert.

Fill it with ice cream (it doesn’t have to be vanilla, but if it is, make sure you get the kind with the little flecks of bean in it). Top it with fresh whipped cream, lightly sweetened. Sprinkle the toasted almond slivers on top, and serve with a bowl of strawberries on the side. We always use the sweetened, frozen ones, because they have lots of juice.

I have one warning. This dessert may make you want to lick your bowl when you have finished scraping up everything you spoon can get to. In my family, while you weren’t allowed to lick your bowl at the table, no one blinked if you took it into the kitchen to get those final drops of strawberry, ice cream and meringue. Yum.

17 thoughts on “Pinch Pie

  1. Katey Schultz

    you really should consider submitting this to a cooking magazine, etc. they’re ALWAYS looking for little vingettes like this that include a recipe and a story. it’s lovely. if you don’t have a copy of the writer’s market 2006 (or 2005) and want some links, i’ll look them up for you. you can get a lot by searching online too.

  2. Aaron

    Wow, what a photo of meringue, did you take that yourself?

    That’s some sort of studio rendition unless you are expert in getting just the right reflection and focus.
    I’m sure your birthday celebration has been splendid, if it’s half as good as that photo.

  3. Marisa

    I would love to put a cook book together someday, that is one of my dreams.

    Aaron, I took that picture all by myself, it’s of the meringue I made yesterday. People who ate it said it was the best meringue I ever made. Kinda nice.

  4. Katey Schultz

    i can put you in touch with a well known cookbook author if you want. she’s great. i’m good friends with her daughter. she’s a wild woman, and as i said – quite successful – but not intimidating. let me know…

  5. aerlyn

    Here is the website I promised 🙂 It was really fun having dinner the other night, we should of photographed that also–I love the pic of the pie!!

  6. Pingback: Apartment 2024 » Blog Archive » Happy Birthday Father O’ Mine

  7. Pingback: Apartment 2024 » Blog Archive » Mini pinch pies

  8. Mr. K

    Just finished listening to an old radio episode of DRAGNET, Big Grandma, where a lady was forging her friends checks for her charities. In the last scene where Sgt Friday goes to her house to take her in she was making a Pinch Pie…. She read off the ingredients in almost the same amounts as listed above.
    Because it is a simple egg white merangue it probably was devised in the depression or because of rationing during WW2 to replace a wheat flour pie crust.
    Icecream, slightly softened, and then re chilled would make a nice presentation with almost any kind of berry topping…
    Back in those days of having very little, in tough times, like today, you can make this in a pinch, for a very lovely desert. Marisa and her grandmother were very lucky people.
    Marisa also posted this on another website,

    1. Tamara K. Spangler

      I just watched this same1951 tv episode of Dragnet. Had to Google pinch pie to see what it was. I am definitely going to try this!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *